16 Reasons Non-Catholic Families Enroll Their Kids in Catholic Schools

Sharing is caring!

Although traditionally linked to the Catholic faith, more non-Catholic families are now opting for Catholic schools. What’s behind this trend? Several compelling reasons are attracting them.

Smaller Class Sizes


Catholic schools often offer smaller class sizes, which many families find preferable. This setup allows for more personalized attention from teachers and reduces the chances of any student being overlooked. 

A lower student-to-teacher ratio can significantly enhance the educational experience, providing a nurturing environment that fosters better academic outcomes. It’s no wonder that some parents, recognizing this benefit, opt for Catholic education—sometimes the decision is as straightforward as comparing class sizes (like one parent whose child enjoys a class of only 11 students!).

A Safer Learning Environment 


Since safety concerns are increasingly prevalent in educational settings, many parents perceive Catholic schools as safer alternatives to their public counterparts. These schools often implement strict safety protocols and maintain a controlled environment that can significantly mitigate the risks and fears associated with school violence. 

This sense of enhanced security might be one of the best reasons for parents to choose Catholic schools, aiming to provide a safer learning atmosphere for their children.

Cost-Effective Private Education Options

Illustration. Image credit: Shutterstock

When comparing the costs of private education, Catholic schools often emerge as a more affordable alternative to other private or prep schools. This affordability makes them an attractive middle ground for families who desire the benefits of private education without the higher expenses associated with elite non-denominational schools. 

For many, Catholic schools offer a balanced option that combines quality education with financial accessibility, appealing to a broad range of families looking for effective yet economical educational solutions.

Cultural Diversity and Inclusion


Catholic schools pride themselves on their commitment to inclusivity and cultural diversity. Despite their religious foundation, these schools welcome students from various cultural, religious, and economic backgrounds. 

This diversity enriches the educational environment by introducing different perspectives and prepares students to succeed in a globally interconnected world. The benefits of such an inclusive atmosphere extend to non-Catholic students as well, who gain valuable insights and develop a well-rounded understanding of the world around them.

Exceptional Sports Programs


Catholic schools often stand out for their robust sports programs, which can be a significant draw for families with young athletes. These institutions are sometimes known for exceptional athletic offerings that foster physical development and even open doors to sports scholarships. 

The quality of these programs can be so high that they attract national attention and produce athletes who excel at collegiate levels, enhancing the appeal of Catholic schools for those seeking superior athletic opportunities.

Quality Education 


Catholic schools are often recognized for their strong educational offerings. Unlike some private institutions that might struggle with resource limitations for diverse student needs, these schools generally maintain a high standard of education. 

They have greater control over their curriculum, enabling them to adapt and cater more effectively to their student body. This autonomy often results in a learning environment that is conducive to educational success, marked by enhanced student engagement and achievement.

A Focused Learning Environment 

Illustration. Image credit: Depositphotos

The ability of Catholic schools to enforce discipline by addressing disruptive behavior directly contributes to a more effective educational atmosphere. This policy benefits the individual learning experience and also improves the overall classroom environment. 

Such measures ensure that all students can benefit from uninterrupted teaching and learning, which is particularly valued by parents seeking a stable and constructive educational setting for their children.

Ensuring Accessibility with Widespread Locations


The Catholic Church, being the largest Christian denomination globally, has a well-established network of schools. This extensive infrastructure enables the placement of Catholic schools in numerous locations, making them more accessible than many Protestant schools, which may lack similar organizational support. 

Parents often find it easier to locate and trust Catholic schools due to their widespread presence and consistent quality, which isn’t always the case with other private educational institutions.

Better Daily Commutes 


For families balancing long work hours and extracurricular commitments, the location of their children’s school plays a key role in easing daily logistics. A slight adjustment in school proximity—like a ten-minute reduction in commute time—can result in saving hours each week. 

This logistical benefit often makes Catholic schools a preferred choice due to their strategic locations, which can be notably closer to parents’ workplaces or homes, facilitating easier and quicker school runs.



Despite the higher costs associated with private education, many Catholic schools actively seek to make their programs accessible to a broader audience through financial aid. Scholarships, grants, and vouchers are commonly offered, reducing the financial burden on families and enabling more students to benefit from a Catholic education. 

This commitment to financial assistance helps ensure that economic barriers do not prevent capable students from accessing the benefits of a Catholic schooling experience.

Integrating Faith and Education 


Even for families that are not strictly Catholic, the religious education provided by Catholic schools can be highly appealing. These schools integrate faith-based learning with general education, offering lessons that encompass moral and ethical development alongside academic achievement. 

This approach caters to Catholic families and attracts those from other denominations or non-religious backgrounds who value a moral framework as part of their children’s education.

Cultivating Strong Moral Foundations 


In today’s diverse educational landscape, many parents are particularly concerned about the moral and ethical influences on their children. Catholic schools are often chosen for their strong emphasis on teaching good values and morals, which can provide a more positive environment compared to public schools. 

According to Virginia Colwell, principal of Paul VI Catholic High School in Fairfax, parents are drawn to the integration of values within daily education, extending moral teachings beyond just the home environment. This focus on character development is a key factor for families seeking an education that reinforces the virtues they value at home, making Catholic schools a preferred choice for fostering integrity and ethical behavior.

Building Strong Character Alongside Academic Skills


In Catholic schools, character development is just as important as academic success. These institutions dedicate significant resources to nurturing qualities like resilience, empathy, and integrity. The emphasis on moral education ensures that students emerge with academic qualifications and as well-rounded individuals ready to contribute positively to society. 

This focus on character formation is particularly beneficial for students from non-Catholic backgrounds, providing them with a solid foundation in universal values that transcend the classroom.

Promoting a Family-Oriented Environment


Many parents value the close-knit community and family atmosphere that Catholic schools are known to foster. Unlike some public schools where teachers may feel burnt out, teachers in Catholic schools often choose their roles based on a passion for education and faith, contributing to a nurturing and supportive educational environment. 

This sense of community enhances the learning experience and builds lasting relationships among students, parents, and educators, making Catholic schools appealing for their strong communal ties.

Offering Fresh Perspectives 


Introducing non-Catholic students to Catholic viewpoints during their formative years can profoundly impact their understanding of the world. Catholic schools provide a grounding in Christian principles and expose students to a diverse array of cultural and socioeconomic backgrounds. 

Over the last 40 years, the landscape of student diversity in Catholic schools has seen notable growth. As per the National Catholic Educational Association, by 2020, racially diverse groups made up 21.2% of the student body in these schools, with Hispanic/Latino students accounting for 18.1% of enrollments. Such environments foster open-mindedness and respect for different viewpoints, preparing students to thrive in a diverse society.

Beyond Academic Learning


Baptist student Myles Sherman of Saint John Paul the Great Catholic High School finds that his education extends beyond academic learning. He believes his experiences will influence his future actions and interactions, particularly in how he engages with people of differing views and non-Christians.

This educational environment broadens his theological perspectives and also equips him with skills to navigate a diverse world.

Continuity in Education During Challenging Times


The COVID-19 pandemic disrupted traditional education systems globally, leading to extended school closures that significantly impacted learning and childcare. Unlike many public schools that remained closed, numerous Catholic schools quickly adapted and reopened, providing much-needed continuity in education and childcare. 

This response was particularly beneficial for working parents needing reliable care and education for their children, highlighting the adaptive and supportive nature of Catholic school communities during crises.

Kate Smith, a self-proclaimed word nerd who relishes the power of language to inform, entertain, and inspire. Kate's passion for sharing knowledge and sparking meaningful conversations fuels her every word.