20 Signs That You’re Dealing with a Fake ‘Nice Guy’ Narcissist

Sharing is caring!

Is the “nice guy” you’re dealing with genuinely kind, or is he disguising deeper narcissistic tendencies? Sometimes, someone can seem almost too perfect, leading you to wonder if it’s all just some great acting skills. You might be dealing with a “fake nice guy” narcissist. 

They ‘Support’ Feminism

Illustration. Image credit: Shutterstock

A “nice guy” narcissist might declare himself a feminist, but his actions often reveal a lack of genuine commitment to gender equality. They may adopt feminist language to win approval and appear progressive, yet their behavior typically exposes a deep-seated sense of entitlement and male privilege. 

To spot a faux feminist, observe how he interacts with and talks about women in his life. Is his empathy selective? For example, he might advocate for workplace equality but react negatively when a female colleague succeeds. Actions speak louder than words, especially when they contradict.

They Lack of Genuine Empathy


A defining characteristic of a narcissist is their inability to genuinely empathize with others. This lack of real emotional connection can make forming deep, meaningful relationships difficult. 

“Nice guy” narcissists may seem empathetic, but their actions often reveal a self-focus. If you notice a pattern where someone appears indifferent to others’ feelings, they could very well be a narcissist.

They Try to Control You


Control can often disguise itself as concern. At first, they may seem caring, but this can quickly shift to excessive control — a red flag for a “nice guy” narcissist. They tend to monitor your movements and get upset if you make plans without them. 

This controlling behavior, whether obvious or subtle, is a classic indication of a “nice guy” narcissist who uses charm to tightly manage the relationship.

They Love Bomb You


Love bombing involves overwhelming someone with affection, attention, and gifts at the beginning of a relationship. This manipulation tactic is designed to quickly forge a strong emotional bond, making you more susceptible to control. If a man showers you with compliments, lavish gifts, and constant communication, claiming you’re soulmates after just a few dates, it’s likely not genuine affection but a strategic move. 

These intense early gestures, while flattering, can mask an attempt to dominate the relationship. Watch for these excessive behaviors as they can indicate underlying manipulative intentions.

They’re Always the ‘Hero’ 


Ever notice how some people always emerge as the hero in their own exaggerated stories? Whether they’re recounting how they saved the day at work or helped someone in need, they’re always front and center. 

While it’s fine to share achievements, a constant hero narrative without any acknowledgment of flaws or errors is a red flag. It suggests an attempt to skew your perception of them, painting themselves in an invariably positive light.

They’re Always the Center of Attention


Someone who always seeks the spotlight can be a red flag, indicating you might be dealing with a “fake nice guy” narcissist. 

Charming and capable of lighting up any room, this person often needs to be the center of attention, frequently steering conversations back to themselves. This behavior of consistently overshadowing others could reveal their true narcissistic traits.

They’re Surrounded by Superficial Friends


Narcissists may struggle to maintain deep, empathetic relationships, often opting instead for a wide circle of superficial acquaintances. These relationships are usually transactional, used by the narcissist for personal gain rather than genuine connection. If the “nice guy” you’re dating seems to have many friends but shallow interactions focused on materialistic or superficial topics, it’s worth taking a closer look. 

Furthermore, a lack of longstanding friendships or estrangement from family can indicate that others have distanced themselves after seeing the narcissist’s true colors.

They Exaggerate Their Abilities

Illustration. Image credit: Shutterstock

Some men exhibit a puzzling level of confidence, like believing they can land a plane with no training. This isn’t always narcissism—often, it’s just unwarranted self-assurance. Still, a “nice guy” narcissist will take this to another level, often exaggerating their talents and achievements to garner admiration. 

They might fish for compliments, boast about minor achievements, or dominate conversations to present themselves in a superior light. While confidence is a good thing, an inflated sense of self-importance and entitlement can signal you’re dealing with a narcissist.

They’re Too Good to Be True

Illustration. Image credit: Depositphotos

Have you encountered someone who seems straight out of a storybook, always polite and doing the right things? This over-the-top perfection can be a sign of a “nice guy” narcissist. 

They often present themselves as the complete package to lure you in. However, if your instincts suggest that their perfection is implausible, it might be time to look closer.

They Refuse to Apologize

Illustration. Image credit: Shutterstock

Rarely will a “nice guy” narcissist say “I’m sorry,” not because they never err, but because admitting fault undermines their inflated self-image. 

Apologizing would mean recognizing a mistake, which narcissists find extremely challenging. They’d rather shift blame or rationalize their actions than admit wrongdoing, often leaving you feeling invalidated and frustrated.

They Can’t Handle Criticism


If you mention even a minor mistake, they react defensively and turn the blame on you. This heightened sensitivity to criticism is common among “nice guy” narcissists. 

Instead of seeing feedback as an opportunity for growth, they take it as a personal attack, showing their incapacity to deal constructively with criticism.

They Never Forget their ‘Favors’

Illustration. Image credit: Shutterstock

Acts of kindness should be genuine and without expectations. However, with a “nice guy” narcissist, every good deed is kept on a mental scorecard. 

At first, their actions—like taking care of you when you’re unwell or paying for meals—may seem caring. But over time, these favors are brought up as debts you owe. If you feel like every act of kindness is being tracked for future repayment, it’s likely not genuine generosity but a manipulation tactic.

They Give You a Guilt Trip 

Illustration. Image credit: Shutterstock

“Nice guy” narcissists excel in manipulation, particularly through guilt. They’ll make you feel remorseful for doing ordinary things like spending time with friends, pursuing hobbies, or taking personal time. 

This manipulation aims to control you by making you feel perpetually indebted to them. If you’re often made to feel guilty without justification, it’s a significant sign of dealing with a narcissistic manipulator.

They Maintain a Robust Social Media Presence

man phone

A strong social media presence doesn’t inherently indicate narcissism, but it can be a red flag. Research suggests narcissists often have more social media connections and post frequently, especially selfies and status updates, seeking validation. 

If your new partner is not an influencer but still constantly updates and posts about themselves, consider this a potential warning sign. Their social media behavior might be more about feeding their ego than sharing their life with friends and family.

They Manipulate Your Perception of Reality


Gaslighting is a subtle yet harmful form of manipulation where someone causes you to doubt your own memories and perceptions. This might begin with simple denials or dismissals and can escalate to you questioning your sanity. 

This gradual erosion of trust in your own senses is a core tactic of manipulation. In a healthy relationship, disagreements are handled with mutual respect for each other’s feelings and perspectives, not by undermining them.

They’re Always the ‘Victim’ of their Exes


When getting to know someone, discussions about past relationships often arise. However, if there’s a consistent narrative from them about being mistreated, misunderstood, or exploited by all their exes, it’s a red flag. 

While anyone can experience a bad relationship, consistently portraying themselves as the perpetual victim in every story, without acknowledging any personal faults or mistakes, signals a problem. True relationships are reciprocal, and it’s seldom solely one person’s fault when things go awry. 

They Disregard Your Emotions


“Nice guy” narcissists often employ this tactic, initially appearing supportive, only to later downplay your feelings, especially if they conflict with their own interests. They might accuse you of overreacting or blame you for your emotions, undermining your self-esteem and mental health. 

If you find that someone consistently disregards your feelings, it’s a clear indication that their “nice guy” facade is just that—a facade.

Their Jealousy Extends Beyond Just About Romance

Illustration. Image credit: Shutterstock

Jealousy can sometimes be a normal part of relationships, but with a “nice guy” narcissist, this feeling isn’t limited to just romantic scenarios—it also affects other areas of your life, like friendships and professional achievements. 

If they respond to your successes with competitiveness or by diminishing your accomplishments, it’s a sign that their support is conditional. Healthy relationships involve celebrating each other’s successes without resentment.

They Exhibit a Grandiose Self-Image

Illustration. Image credit: Shutterstock

A grandiose self-perception is a hallmark of narcissistic personality disorder, and it’s prevalent among “nice guy” narcissists. They believe themselves to be exceptional and deserving of special treatment. 

This inflated self-view often comes with expectations of constant admiration and a belief that they are superior to others. Encountering someone who consistently acts as if they’re above everyone else usually indicates narcissistic traits.

They Isolate You from Your Support Network


A “nice guy” narcissist might subtly start to sever your connections with friends and family, under the guise of them not being good for you. They manipulate scenarios to make you reliant solely on them, both for emotional support and social interaction. 

This isolation tactic aims to increase your dependence on them, making it harder for you to seek perspectives outside of the relationship. 

Kate Smith, a self-proclaimed word nerd who relishes the power of language to inform, entertain, and inspire. Kate's passion for sharing knowledge and sparking meaningful conversations fuels her every word.